PYP 144: Irving Kirsch on Harnessing the Placebo Effect and Discovering the Truth about Antidepressants
Irving Kirsch is a soft-spoken researcher who accidentally stumbled upon one of the biggest and most costly errors in modern medicine. His cautious yet relentless search for the truth has made him persona non grata to much of the psychiatric profession and pharmaceutical industry, and a hero to the rest of us.
His findings, documented in his book The Emperor’s New Drugs as well as in dozens of published papers and book chapters, has generated a lot of controversy, including a 5-page cover story in Newsweek and a segment on 60 Minutes.
His conclusion: antidepressant drugs, including blockbusters like Prozac and Paxil, don’t work. They’re no better than placebo, meaning the only reason people feel and get better when they take those drugs is because they believe they will.
When you look at the evidence collected and analyzed and curated by Kirsch, it’s hard to disagree.
Read More





